Restaurants

Papa Pirelli's

4.8 122 reviews Closed 613 E La Salle Ave, Barron, WI 54812, United States

Discover this place

At Papa Pirelli's, located in Barron, Wisconsin, diners are treated to an array of Italian-American delights, particularly their renowned stuffed rollo calzones, which include options like the Veggie and Chicken Bacon Ranch, all priced at $17.99. The menu also boasts a selection of hot Italian grinders and submarines, ensuring there's something for every palate.

Customer reviews highlight the exceptional service and delicious food that make Papa Pirelli's a popular choice for lunch or dinner. Kori Novinski raved about the convenience of delivery, praising the cheesy garlic bread and unique ability to customize their rollo. Similarly, Angie Linngren commended the staff's friendliness and the standout flavors of the taco pizza.

Mariah Grotzinger's experience with the Papa Fire Rollo, a spicy yet balanced choice, evokes the joy of discovering the perfect flavor profile—she noted how her daughter loved her own mini pizza, showcasing the family-friendly atmosphere. Donna Keagle's appreciation for the Chicago-style stuffed supreme pizza, laden with fresh toppings and a rich sauce, confirms that each dish is crafted with care.

Whether you're craving a hearty calzone or a flavorful grinder, Papa Pirelli's promises a memorable dining experience that leaves patrons eager to return for more.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Dining options

Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating

Amenities

Restroom

Crowd

Family-friendly

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Papa Pirelli's before visiting.

Reviews for Papa Pirelli's

4.8

122 reviews

100%

Review highlights

Based on 122 reviews

Papa Pirelli's is widely praised for its flavorful and diverse menu, featuring standout items like specialty pizzas, calzones, and unique rolls with well-balanced spices. Customers appreciate the generous toppings and quality ingredients, highlighting items such as taco pizzas and Chicago-style stuffed pizzas. The restaurant receives frequent commendations for its friendly, attentive staff and reliable delivery service. While some wish for extended operating hours, many recognize the value and quality offered, making the slightly longer wait times worthwhile. Overall, Papa Pirelli's is celebrated for its customer-centric approach, consistent food quality, and a menu that appeals to a variety of tastes, encouraging repeat visits and experimentation with new dishes.

Kori Novinski

Jul 17, 2025

We decided to order from Papa Pirelli's for lunch today. BEST DECISION EVER! Created my own Rolo, and we got Cheesy Garlic Bread. Had it delivered to our office. The delivery driver was very polite! Definetly worth the price and little bit of a wait. We will be ordering again. Can't wait to try something different next time!

Angie Linngren

Jul 12, 2025

GREAT customer service, the staff is super friendly! The food was amazing. We ordered a taco pizza that was soo good! The two calzones did not disappoint! My husband ordered the Firecracker calzone and he LOVED it!!

Kevin Vender

Jul 06, 2025

Love their pizza! Wish they were open more days but totally get it. Always friendly! Pizza is awesome and always made and ready fast!

Mariah Grotzinger

Jul 02, 2025

The food was amazing, and well worth the price! The Papa Fire Rollo was just the perfect amount of spice without it being to spicy to eat. My daughter fell in love with having her own mini pizza, and my husband was able to get a gyro that left him speechless because he was too busy eating it as fast as he could. Definitely recommend the taco pizza, especially as leftovers cold! . Like I said overall a great place to order food, and can't wait to order again!

Donna Keagle

Jun 11, 2025

Got a Chicago style stuffed supreme pizza. It was amazing! Perfect amount of sauce cheese. All the veggies and olives and meat made the best taste!

Jody Elmquist

May 31, 2025

Great fresh food! This crust..and the cheesy garlic toast...and the gyro pizza! It is all so yummy.

Rissa Rhoades

Apr 18, 2025

We had appetizers, sandwiches, pizza, and the cinnamon twists for dessert. Everything was 5 stars. Literally the best pizza I've had, hands down. We were here when it was uptown pizza, and caddyshack, and neither one of them could hold a flame to the level of amazingness coming out of their ovens. If you haven't been, you 100% need to go!!!